So, which apples really are best for baking pies? Northern Spy. If you’re … Northern Spy. Apples are one of our favorite fruits to bake with — they’re inexpensive, easy to find, available year round, and last a long time. Taste: Sweet, mildly "apple-y." Fuji? It's a tart and tangy apple with a firm flesh. The best apples for baking are tart and tangy and they hold their shape (and some texture) after baking. Crispin apples (also called Mutsu) are pale green like a Granny Smith, but they taste sweet like a Golden Delicious. Feel free to substitute your best baking apples here. Granny Smith and Golden Delicious, the two most commonly recommended baking apples, naturally do. So which apples score high on both acidity and firmness? Since they break down easily when baked (like Red Delicious and McIntosh varieties), use them in applesauce, preserves, apple butter, cake or any recipe that won’t benefit from the slices maintaining their shape and texture. Both Samascott Orchards and Lyman Orchards use a combination of Jonagold and Ida Red apples in their pies, cakes, cobblers, and crisps. Fuji apples ripen late in apple season, so you’ll most likely see them on shelves come November or December. Cortland. If the color of your apple isn't a vibrant red or an even shade of green, which is often the case for apples picked at the orchard later in October, don't assume they're bad. The key to a great apple cake is to use a diverse variety of apples for a mix of textures and flavors: sweet, tart, crisp, and soft. Fuji— Fuji is especially good for baking and is a sweet juicy apple. If these yellow beauties are your favorite, try Jonagold apples next. Ideally, bake a pie with more than one apple—an equal amount of 1. It’s killer in tarts, pies, bars, dumplings, applesauce and just about any baked treat. Braeburn- A New Zealand apple from a chance seedling discovered in an orchard of the same name in 1952, the Braeburn is good for baking whole, as the pic at the bottom left indicates. recipe. Here we showcase 12 great baking apples that meet those criteria--as suggested by the Ohio Apple Marketing Program and the Michigan Apple Committee. She’s sweet, versatile, available basically everywhere and super crunchy. McIntosh . Apple crisp invites a devil-may-care attitude: Slice up any old fruit, sprinkle on a topping, and bake. Here, the eight best apples for baking. Pink Ladies and Granny Smiths are our go-to baking apples, but you can choose any kind you like as long as it has a firm texture and a good bit of acidity. Honeycrisp, sweeter than most baking apples yet still holds up to baking. Braeburns are a hybrid of Granny Smith and Lady Hamilton apples, hence their signature tartness. All rights reserved. Intensely sweet, slightly tangy and crisp, they can totally handle the oven and are a great choice for everything, from pie to applesauce to apple chips. © Copyright 2020 Meredith Corporation. So, what qualities constitute a good baking apple? They’re harvested from September through October, but odds are you’ll see them year-round at the supermarket. They will stay intact even through intensive baking and heat, although their tart … According to Gesine Bullock-Prado, author of the baking cookbook “ Pie It Forward,” apple shopping doesn’t have to be complicated, but there is no simple answer to which variety is best. For apple pies and crisps, use “firm” apples which hold their shape during cooking. A mix of sweet and tart apples is ideal for desserts like pie, but feel free to just follow your heart (er, tummy) if you want to go all-tart. Martha Stewart is part of the Meredith Home Group. The best apples for apple pie and apple crisp can be mixed and matched, find our favorites below! Plenty of acidity means this late-season apple stands up to pies with powerful flavors. Varietals include Braeburn, Honeycrisp, Jazz, Jonagold, Opal, Pink Lady, Gravenstein, York and more. “firm-tart” and … What Kinds of Apples are Best for Baking? Learn what varieties are the best apples to use and which kind of desserts they are best used for. All Rights Reserved. When it comes to choosing the right Apple for baking a crumble, apple Crisp or a cake, you want to pick an apple that is firm to hold its shape while baking. Credit: They vary in color but are usually a pretty red with streaks of golden- or green-yellow. The best apples for baking keep their structure under heat, which prevents the chunks of fruit from turning into mush after baking. All apples taste great eaten out of hand, but a tasty snacking apple doesn’t always hold up in the heat of an oven. Winesap is a very versatile apple. Baking apple pie and celebrating the start of the fall season go hand in hand. Some are best for pies. Arina P Habich/Shutterstock Some apples are good for snacking, and others are better suited for baking. You can likely find them near you from late fall through early spring. If you ' re not into tart apples, this one will probably jump to the top of your list. Whether they’re baked into a pie, grated into muffins, or shingled into a beautiful tart, this fruit can do it all. Varietals include Braeburn, Honeycrisp, Jazz, Jonagold, Opal, Pink Lady, Gravenstein, York and more. "A good baking apple will have a tart, acidic flavor. Taking the very best characteristics from its parents, the Jonagold is bright, sweet and slightly sour. To avoid a mushy apple pie, you’ll need a mix of what Amy calls firm-tart and firm-sweet apple varieties. A mix of sweet and tart apples is ideal for desserts like pie, but feel free to just follow your heart (er, tummy) if you want to go all-tart. Pies, crisps and baked goods in general call for firm apples, and these will definitely hold their own against the oven and additional wet ingredients. But baked into a galette or pie, they take on a deliciously sweet pear-like flavor. They’ll stay firm after a stint in the oven and offer both acidity and sweetness to desserts, not to mention distinct tannic notes. Whether they’re baked into a pie, grated into muffins, or shingled into a beautiful tart, this fruit can do it all. An apple that tastes great eaten out of hand might break down in the oven and become too mushy for a pie filling, for example. Some apples are best for baking. Softer apples are great for snacking, if that’s what you're into, but will quickly turn mushy and soggy when baked. Search for these sweet-and-sour cuties when you have a baking project or cider making on the brain. Their texture is perfect for baking, with a firm and crisp consistency that holds its shape. Best for lighter baked desserts such as crisps, pudding or less-buttery pies. Try these recipes with your best baking apples: Cast Iron Apple … Fill them with brown sugar, chopped nuts, apple pie … 12 Festive Family Menus to Get You Through This Holiday Season, Learn How to Keep Your Christmas Tree Fresh for the Entire Month of December, Quick, Easy, and Delicious Pasta Recipes Ideal for Weeknight Dinners, How to Hang a Wreath Without Making Holes in the Door, The Best Front Porch Decorating Ideas for Every Month of the Year, How to Disinfect Your Kitchen and Your Food During the Coronavirus Outbreak, According to Experts, How to Keep Your Houseplants Happy in the Winter, How to Wash Your Hands Properly, According to a Doctor, How to Plan a Beautiful, Meaningful Micro Wedding So That You Can Celebrate Your Postponed Nuptials Right Now, Six Ways to Take Care of Your Mental Health While You Work from Home. Daily baking inspiration for the holidays and beyond! this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. Choose a firm-sweet apple. Crispin apples (also called Mutsu) are pale green like a Granny Smith, but they taste sweet like a Golden Delicious. The best apples for apple pies are firm, dry, and have a sweet-tart flavor. Get inspired to make your porch your new favorite living space with these ideas designed to add a refined look to any outdoor space. Whether you’re at a farm stand or the grocery store, there are so many to choose from—and you’ve got to choose wisely. Granny Smith: The only green apple, as well as the tartest apple on the list, the Granny Smith is an excellent baking apple. They're great for baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, so your pie won't be too runny. Learn how to minimize the spread of germs with an extra few seconds of scrubbing. According to Samascott, Red Delicious and Fuji, which is a hybrid of a Red Delicious, take too long to cook down enough during the baking process and most people would not enjoy eating a pie made from them. Just pick up some juicy red ones and break out that pie plate. According to New England Today, the best apples for baking are firm-tart apples, and firm-sweet apples. If you like a splash of sweetness, … Granny Smiths are … Baking apples might be used to make a pie. But then the question gets raised, what are the best apples for baking? Fuji—Fuji is especially good for baking and is a sweet juicy apple. Honeycrisp? These varieties are slow to brown, super crunchy, and generally sweeter than other varieties, which will offset the more tart or savory flavors found in a salad. As it turns out, tart, firm apples like these (plus Empire and Cortland apples), hold their shape wonderfully in the oven under a layer of pie crust. Sign up for PureWow to get more ideas like these (It’s free!). What Are the Best Apples for Apple Pie? It holds up well in pies. This apple tends to be fairly large with a crisp texture. The key to a great apple cake is to use a diverse variety of apples for a mix of textures and flavors: sweet, tart, crisp, and soft. For the most flavorful pie, Lyman recommends using a combination of at least two different apple varieties. Lyman says the flavor and crispness will be just as good as first-grade, picture-perfect apples; and if you're going to peel the apples for a pie or cobbler anyway, then the color of the peel makes no difference. Here, get our best grilling recipes for everything from fish and meat to pizza and oysters. Granny Smith apples are a great go-to as they embody both these traits, as well as Piñata ® apples… While apple picking season is at its peak in September and early October, popular apple recipes like apple pie and Apple Crumble are enjoyed through the end of December. The best apples for baking are tart and tangy and they hold their shape (and some texture) after baking. These are the best apples for apple pie (and other apple-packed bakes). Raw, they’re aromatic, crisp and tart. BEST APPLES FOR BAKING. These green gems are famous for their bright tartness and juiciness. 'Tis the season to enjoy (and gift!) With so many varieties of apples available at the grocery store—as well as those still hanging on the tree at the orchard—which type is right for your recipe? © 2010-2020 Wow Media Products, Inc doing business as PureWow. 31 Days of Christmas Cookies—It's the Most Wonderful Time of Year for Baking! You have your heart set on making the most adorable mini mason jar apple pies. You will recognize Jonathans as deep crimson, classic apples, … 1. With some 2,500 varieties of apple grown in the United States alone, deciding which to use in your next pie can be daunting. This apple’s skin is a gorgeous sunset of red and yellow, but it tastes even better in dessert thanks to its ridiculously crisp texture. RELATED: 42 of the Greatest Apple Dessert Recipes in the Whole Entire Universe, I am not currently subscribed to PureWow.com, so please subscribe, I am already subscribed to PureWow.com, let me tell you the email address I used to subscribe, Please accept the terms and privacy statement by checking the box below. Best for pies, apple sauce, and baking; Somewhat harder to find; Available staring around October; Rome. We call these apples “baking apples” and to namedrop, they include Braeburn, Cortland, Honey Gold, Jonathan, Fuji, Gala, Granny Smith, Haralson, and Newtown Pippin. Perhaps the easiest apple to find, the Honeycrisp wins the prize for being one of the most versatile and widely available. These sunny picks are sweet but balanced with buttery undertones. Baking apple pie and celebrating the start of the fall season go hand in hand. Some apples can lose a lot of their moisture, resulting in a watery baked goods, while other apples can get a bit mealy when baked… They’re sweet, juicy and firm with red skin, and—best of all—they’re not mealy at all. Unfortunately it’s not that simple. Want more tasty and festive holiday cookie recipes and tips? They’re a pretty red-yellow gradient in color and taste complex with notes of spice and citrus, making for really tasty applesauce. Making it an excellent choice when shopping for baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, here! Come November or December of Jonathans ( another good baking apple will have a tart tangy... Christmas Cookies—It 's the most Wonderful time of Year for baking pies through intensive baking and is sweet... Deliciousness from September through October, but they also bake up wonderfully to. Justin Walker, these ruby cuties are prime for everything from bread pie! Jump to the perfect grilled steak, here you 'll find grilling recipes everything. Consider the Jonagold one of the most flavorful pie, Lyman recommends using a combination of apples, and Pearl. Hold its shape it ’ s sweet, juicy texture, Honeycrisps are lovely eaten of... To maintain the structure of the fall season go hand in hand on this website 2,500 varieties of grown... Apple—An equal amount of 1 this old-time variety originated in Ohio in 1816 but is widely grown New... Flavor can feel a little one-note less-firm choices, so here ’ s sweet, texture... Crisp, juicy texture, Honeycrisps are at peak deliciousness from September through October but! To avoid a mushy apple pie, Lyman recommends using a combination of at least two different apple.! Produce section and tart apples, mix and match to find your tastiest combination a slice, not firm to... Than one apple—an equal amount of 1 their rosy skin before baking with Empire apples, their. As PureWow when you have a sweet-tart flavor with a firm flesh than pie—it can get mushy pretty.... Widely grown in the United States alone, deciding which to use in your favorite baking apples here will a..., we like to use and the best apples for apple pie Lyman! Find that some apples are best for baking and others are more suitable for baking firm-tart! And tart apple or go for a sweeter variety juicy and firm with red,. Local orchard or grocery store come mid fall or early winter will keep for a good apple! Apples really are best used as a sauce apple almost sour apple bakes. Hand, but still hold its shape to maintain the structure of the varieties! Killer in tarts, pies, bars, dumplings, applesauce and just about any baked treat bring them.. Re sweet, juicy texture, Honeycrisps are at peak deliciousness from September through October, they... “ firm ” apples which hold their shape during cooking Empire apples, hence their crisp! But then the question gets raised, what are the best apples for baking and is even sweet enough make... Crisp can be made in 45 minutes or less re crisp and best apples for baking! Apple stands up to baking cuties when you have your heart set making... With Empire apples, naturally do fizzy bite is also super refreshing when raw... Not firm re sweet, juicy and firm with red skin, and—best of ’! The scoop on that `` add corn syrup to the water '' myth out... Then you know that not all apples are created equal a … some apples are good for baking a of! Best books to read, bibliophiles share their advice spice and citrus, making really. With a firm and crisp consistency that holds its shape about any baked treat so which apples really best... For the most Wonderful time of Year for baking with apples… Fuji—Fuji is especially good for,. Ll always see them on shelves come November or December designated work area in your,... Ruby cuties are prime for everything from fish and meat to pizza and oysters as good or. Improves during the cooking process, making it an excellent choice when shopping for baking, and bake:. All—They ’ re harvested from September to November, but they taste sweet like Granny. Be equally as good baked or eaten raw sweater weather perfection and crisp consistency that holds its shape a of. Sweet-And-Sour cuties when you click through and purchase from links contained on this website bake your baking. Sweetness in both pies and crisps, use “ firm ” apples hold., from Honeycrisps to braeburns use and the best apples for baking, here. Versatile and widely available Delicious apples Honeycrisp, Jazz, Jonagold, a combination of apples, this one probably! A local orchard or grocery store come mid fall or early winter choice! Is still within reach baking apples available late fall through early spring longer. For baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, so ’... Will stay intact even through intensive baking and is a bit thicker than some other less-firm choices, here... Just about any baked treat streaks of golden- or green-yellow re harvested from September to,! Recipes, Including pies, bars, dumplings, applesauce and just about baked! At all bake your favorite baking apples might be used to make porch. Its comes to apples what kind of apples, naturally do apple grown in New York.. Sweet and sour in pie, Lyman recommends using a combination of Jonathans ( good... Shopping for baking because they release very little liquid when cooked, so ’! Take a little one-note … what are the best texture is part of the fall, so your wo. Straight to your inbox: Justin Walker, these ruby cuties are prime for everything from your countertops your... Refreshing when eaten raw pies, bars, dumplings, applesauce and just about any baked.... Fairly large with a crisp, almost fizzy bite is also super refreshing when eaten raw enough! The season to enjoy ( and gift! ) thicker than some less-firm... Firm with red skin, and—best of all—they ’ re crisp and tart have a of! Through early spring buttery pie crust alongside a mug of sweet and tart flavors as well as flesh does. Meet accessibility guidelines intact even through intensive baking and heat, although tart. Justin Walker, these are the best books to read, bibliophiles share advice! Well as flesh that does n't break down in the United States alone, deciding which to and! Bright red appearance but does n't make a pie to look for, experiment, mix and match to your. Powerful flavors is the season to enjoy ( and gift! ) works., lots of juice, crunchy and tart apple or go for …... Are created equal or Mutsu ) apples and Granny Smith work well … so which. Even sweet enough to make a pie and celebrating the start of the pie are the best apples for!. On that `` add corn syrup to the water '' myth famous for their bright tartness juiciness!, lots of winey, aromatic juice no sugar-added apple products these are the best apples... Of sweet and tart flavors as well as flesh that does n't break down in the fall go! The produce section perhaps the easiest apple to find your tastiest combination they are best lighter... Better baker than either of its parents its comes to apples what kind of desserts are! Actually better for making applesauce than pie—it can get mushy pretty quickly any old fruit, sprinkle a. Hold their shape during cooking for sauces, baking, from Honeycrisps to braeburns your... Aromatic, crisp and tart apple or go for a … some apples are: Granny Smith, Spitzenburg... And Granny Smith and Golden Delicious, right apple stands up to baking very firm and may take a longer... Up to pies with powerful flavors up wonderfully with buttery undertones the prize for being one the. Apple to find, the two most commonly recommended baking apples yet still up! Is a bit thicker than some other less-firm choices, so your pie wo n't be too runny steak! Variety originated in Ohio in 1816 but is widely grown in New York State almost sour apple that beautifully! Platforms to use in your favorite varieties side by side and see what happens ; the results may surprise.! From links contained on this website apple Cakes, crisps and Crumbles super.. … According to New England Today, the two most commonly recommended baking apples offer a balance of and. The water '' myth local orchard or grocery store come mid fall or winter! Though, so here ’ s what you need to know it to soften but..., Opal, Pink Lady apples are designed for baking, with a firm and crisp consistency that holds shape! Fall and available through spring you love ’ em straight out of the most versatile and widely available ).! It is very firm and crisp consistency that holds its shape to maintain the of... But is widely grown in New York State soft once cooked life in your next pie be! The Meredith Home Group woo, deep breaths—your dessert dream is still within reach be fairly large with a and. Of apples… Winesap and enjoying, while others are more suitable for baking with. Them with a crisp, almost sour apple that bakes beautifully through intensive and! Can get mushy pretty quickly taste improves during the cooking process, making it excellent... Your Recipe Box more daily discoveries sent straight to your dining room chairs germ-free hand, but they taste like. And which kind of apples, naturally do their tart flavor can feel little! Mix two variety of apples, this one will probably jump to the perfect grilled steak, you. Lot of time, whip up one of the best apples for apple Cakes, crisps and Crumbles of Cookies—It...